BOOK REVIEW: Albert’s Time, by Marc Bookman

BOOK REVIEW

Albert’s Time, Marc Bookman, Black Rose Writing, 2026, 296 pages, $20.95

To save Albert’s life, we needed to climb the mountain of vitriol his case had created in the community, get to the other side, and ask two very different questions: Do you believe in human frailty? And if you do, can you forgive a person who refuses to forgive himself?

I first encountered Marc Bookman, who spent 28 years as a Philadelphia public defender before co-founding the Atlantic Center for Capital Representation, through A Descending Spiral, his collection of essays on the death penalty and the many ways the system can go wrong. What struck me then was not only Bookman’s experience as a capital-defense lawyer but also the way he wrote about a subject that invites easy indignation without resorting to it. He let the facts speak. He peeled away the layers of misconduct, bias, incompetence, and capriciousness, allowing readers to see for themselves what is wrong with a system that can take a human life in the name of justice; killing to show that killing is wrong.

When I came to Albert’s Time, I expected another book, albeit a work of fiction, about the death penalty. It is something quite different, and, in its own way, just as compelling. It is not a fast-paced read. It is a slow burner, taking you from the serene setting of what appears to be a relaxing, undoubtedly well-earned fishing trip on the banks of a lake in Quebec to a courtroom in Philadelphia.

Bookman is no John Grisham, who spins an engaging fast paced tale with a social message. Nor is he a Michael Connelly, whose Lincoln Lawyer, Mickey Haller, is clever, entertaining, and at times ethically challenged, convinced that his reasons and methods are righteous, yet consumed by publicity, fame, and money. Grisham and Connelly know how to keep the pages turning, and after an exhausting day or during a respite at the beach, they are like fast food when famished, hitting the spot.

Don’t get me wrong. Bookman, an ardent opponent of the death penalty who understands the complexities and nuances of defending clients charged with capital offenses, is more than a capable writer and a fine storyteller. He is simply doing something else.

What distinguishes Albert’s Time is not merely its argument against capital punishment. It is the attention Bookman gives to the person who must defend someone facing it. The dialogue may not always flow as effortlessly as in a Grisham or Connelly novel, and the story may meander at times, but Bookman shines as a chronicler of the inner thoughts, doubts, demons, and self-criticism of a death-penalty defense lawyer.

That lawyer, Simon Koufax, is a public defender. The late Charles Ogletree, himself a formidable former public defender in Washington, D.C., and later a Harvard law professor, wrote in his seminal article “Beyond Justifications: Seeking Motivations to Sustain Public Defenders” that public defenders are sustained by a combination of empathy and heroism: the ability to identify with the client and the willingness to fight against the odds on the client’s behalf. The description fits Koufax particularly well. He must fight. He must persuade. He must understand people whom others have already judged. And he must keep doing it even when the case begins to consume the rest of his life.

Death is different.

When someone is beaten, assaulted, raped, or otherwise grievously injured, the consequences may be permanent. Physical and psychological wounds may never fully heal. Yet the person remains alive. There is still a possibility of recovery, however remote. Death closes that possibility forever.

Representing someone facing the death penalty is different as well. The difference is not simply the punishment. It is the consequence of getting something wrong. Regardless of the strength of the evidence against the accused, every strategic and tactical decision is made with the understanding that an error may determine whether the client lives or dies. The investigation, the evidence, the experts, the witnesses, the jury, the arguments, and even decisions that might seem insignificant in an ordinary case take on a different weight. There is little room for error because there is no meaningful way to undo the ultimate mistake.

And if the defense succeeds, the victory can seem almost absurd to anyone who has never represented a capital defendant. The client does not go free. He may spend the rest of his life in prison without the possibility of parole. The victory is simply that he will have the rest of his life.

There is, nevertheless, always the possibility of finding something. Something buried in a family history, in trauma or abuse, in a medical record, in a relationship, or in an event that occurred years before the crime. Something that may humanize the client. Something that may persuade a prosecutor to accept a sentence of life imprisonment rather than death, or persuade a jury that the person before them is more than the worst thing they have done.

The death penalty defense lawyer’s task is to find it.

Sister Helen Prejean, author of Dead Man Walking, captures something of the book’s power in her testimonial to Albert’s Time, writing that readers “will not soon forget the characters or the truths they illuminate about vengeance and forgiveness.” Testimonials of this kind are often generous. I tend to be skeptical of them, especially when they appear on a book’s cover and promise more than the book can deliver. In this instance, however, Sister Helen got it right.

I waited a couple of weeks before writing this review because Albert’s Time kept seeping into my thoughts. Not because of the horrors at its center, but because of the questions beneath them. What does it mean to defend someone who has done something terrible? What does it mean to ask twelve people to spare his life? And what happens to the lawyer who spends months or years searching for reasons why his client should live, when the client himself may not believe he should? These questions are not new to me, and I have reflected on them during and after my public defender days, which is one reason Albert’s Time proved a compelling, contemplative read.

That is the world into which Simon Koufax enters.

Koufax is an experienced public defender who has represented people facing the death penalty. He knows the terrain and the anxiety that come with it. He also knows the peculiar professional temptation that accompanies a difficult capital case. It is a high-profile case. It is another mountain to climb. There is professional pride in taking on the challenge, and perhaps something less noble as well: the belief that, somehow, you are the person who can save this particular client.

That belief can be dangerous.

The case begins to consume Koufax, as capital cases can. His professional responsibility becomes a personal obligation. The client’s fate begins to occupy the space normally reserved for family, friends, and ordinary life. Beneath the immediate task of defending his client, Albert, lies another burden. Koufax carries the memory of an earlier death-penalty case. Young and inexperienced, he failed a client who insisted on representing himself. Assigned as backup and certainly able to assist, he sat in court like a potted plant, never uttering a sound, an objection, or a legal argument that might at least have preserved errors for appeal. The old failure has not disappeared. It has simply been buried beneath years of experience.

Now he has another chance.

Albert Birdsong, a part-time English graduate student and substitute teacher with no history of trouble, stabbed Malcolm Hawthorne, a charismatic, well-liked local soccer star, Princeton graduate, and hedge fund manager, and shot Johnny Renault, a 12-year-old boy whom Albert had babysat and planned to take to the zoo on the day of the shooting. Albert called the police, waited at the scene, and matter-of-factly confessed to the killings, offering no explanation. Guilt was therefore not in dispute. The trial would turn on the sentencing phase, where, unlike in a noncapital case, the jury would decide between life in prison and death.

Without giving away the plot, the circumstances surrounding Malcolm’s killing can, to some extent, be understood in light of certain facts, facts Albert does not want presented to the jury. The killing of Johnny is harder to comprehend and even harder to accept. Albert eventually reveals to Koufax the reasons for what he did, but the explanation does not necessarily make the act any easier to understand. Even then, the jury never hears it.

Perhaps that is one of the book’s uncomfortable truths. Human beings sometimes do things that defy logic, their character, and ordinary human understanding. We may know what someone did without understanding why. Understanding is not the same as excusing, and explaining is not the same as justifying. Yet the defense lawyer has to try to understand enough to explain the person to others.

That requires something more than legal skill. It requires empathy.

For Koufax, understanding is not optional. His task is to find reasons not to kill his client. As he puts it, “Death penalty investigation is a search for reasons not to kill your client.” Those reasons are mitigating circumstances that may be everywhere, often buried beneath layers of trauma, abuse, records, and events that occurred long before the crime. The lawyer must find them, understand them, and somehow make them matter to twelve people who must decide whether another human being should live.

But Albert poses a problem that no investigation can easily resolve. He does not seem particularly interested in helping Koufax save him. The problem is not that he does not understand what is at stake. It may be that he understands it too well. Albert knows what he has done. He knows that one of his victims was an innocent child. He also appears to believe that whatever happens to him is deserved.

This is where the question of forgiveness, and perhaps absolution, enters the story.

Can a person who cannot forgive himself accept that others might forgive him? Can a person who believes he deserves to die be persuaded that his life still has value? And what happens when the person fighting hardest for that life may be doing so for reasons that have as much to do with himself as with his client?

These questions hang in the air as Koufax exposes Albert to Viktor Frankl’s Man’s Search for Meaning, a book I had first read some forty years ago and serendipitously happened to be rereading as I picked up Albert’s Time.

In several passages, Frankl quotes Friedrich Nietzsche: “He who has a why to live for can bear almost any how.” Frankl knows this firsthand, having spent years as a prisoner in Auschwitz and other concentration camps. In his account of the camps, he describes the why as what kept him going. That is central to his understanding of how a person survives suffering: meaning gives purpose to endurance. For Albert, however, the problem is that the why appears to have disappeared. No matter what Koufax tells him or tries to do to help him, Albert has no way of bearing the how.

If he cannot forgive himself for what he has done, particularly for killing the boy, perhaps the distinction between life imprisonment and death has little meaning to him. Life without the possibility of parole is not necessarily frightening if there is no life he wants to live. And death may not be frightening either. If there is no why to live, the how may cease to matter.

That may help explain Albert’s willingness to accept his fate and his reluctance to provide the information that might allow Koufax to develop the mitigation needed to save him. It is not necessarily that Albert wants to die. It may be that he no longer sees a reason to live.

Perhaps a death sentence offers him something else: absolution.

That is necessarily an interpretation. The novel does not give us a simple explanation, and perhaps it should not. We cannot know exactly what Albert is thinking. But that possibility gives his passivity a different meaning. He may not be surrendering merely to punishment. He may believe that death is the only appropriate way to pay for what he has done.

Koufax presents the opposite problem.

He is fighting for a life that his client has all but given up. The more he fights, the harder it becomes to separate his duty to Albert from his own need to succeed. He carries the failure of his first capital case with him. He may believe that if he can save Albert, he can finally prove to himself that he is no longer the young lawyer who failed another client.

At the same time, he is grappling with a prosecutor who has decided to seek the death penalty and appears unmoved by Koufax’s efforts to persuade him otherwise. Koufax repeatedly appeals to the prosecutor’s better nature, urging him to accept what would amount to a sentence of life without parole. He knows the effort is probably futile. But he keeps trying, to the point of groveling.

Realistically, what else does he have to offer? The killing of an innocent child is a bridge too far for even a more merciful prosecutor, particularly when the community is stoked by anger and vengeance and by a perverted sense that justice in such cases can come only by inflicting the ultimate punishment. Koufax can argue that the State should not compound the tragedy of two lives lost by taking another, even if that taking is sanctioned by law. But he has little else to bargain with.

In that sense, saving Albert may be a form of redemption for Koufax.

Albert may be looking for absolution through death. Koufax may be looking for it through life.

The symmetry is imperfect, and perhaps that is what makes it compelling. Koufax cannot simply impose his wish for Albert to live. His job is to defend Albert, not to decide what Albert should believe about his own life. Yet a capital defender must often fight for a client who does not know how or does not want to fight for himself.

That is the burden of the work. The defender must find something worth saving even when the client cannot see it.

There is, however, another dimension to Koufax’s struggle. The judge is also a known quantity, and not a favorable one. She appears strongly pro-prosecution, and Koufax suspects she is determined to see the jury condemn Albert to death, perhaps in part because a death verdict might help her secure elevation to the state’s highest court. That may sound cynical, particularly because she is not the person who will impose the sentence. But a judge can, within the margins of discretion, make rulings that affect the course of a trial and, ultimately, the weight of the evidence before the jury. It is naïve to think that judges, particularly elected judges, are beyond such behavior.

What struck me more was not Koufax’s suspicion of the judge but what he does with it. When she rejects the defense psychiatrist’s testimony for seemingly sound reasons, Koufax does not insist on making an offer of proof by having the expert testify under oath, outside the jury’s presence, about what his evidence would be. Doing so would at least have preserved the testimony for the record and any subsequent appeal. Had he done so, the judge’s reasoning might have been subject to meaningful review rather than leaving Koufax to speculate about her motives.

The final answer from the defense’s last witness also seems to have opened the door, ever so slightly, to a renewed request that the judge reconsider her ruling.

These are points I notice as a defense lawyer, not necessarily as an ordinary reader. Perhaps pursuing them further would have complicated the plot, but I think not. Bookman is far too good and far too diligent a lawyer not to appreciate the need to build a record of the judge’s errors and preserve them for appeal. Koufax knows as much. So what gives? I am left wondering whether Koufax’s failure to preserve the record was simply a plot device or another way of showing what happens to even the best defenders under extraordinary pressure. A defender who is exhausted, frightened, invested in the outcome, and carrying the weight of an earlier failure can falter, even when the lapse is not caused by haste or lack of diligence. I know firsthand what it is to reflect on errors I made and be at a loss to explain them. Not every error has an obvious cause or a logical explanation.

Sometimes the passion to save a client can cloud judgment. And when the client is facing the death penalty, a defender who has little to work with but is weighed down by empathy, and perhaps by guilt as well, can become almost consumed by the need to find a way forward. Exhaustion, fear, and despair do not necessarily diminish that passion. They can intensify it, leading to strategic and tactical errors.

That, too, is part of what makes Koufax interesting.

There were, of course, smaller pleasures along the way. At one point, Koufax relaxes to the sounds of Bill Evans, particularly his soothing “Peace Piece.” Though I listen to Bill Evans almost daily, this tune, in this context, brought back memories I had not expected the book to stir. There is a discussion of The Verdict, a film I had recently watched again for the umpteenth time, less for its courtroom drama than for its themes of redemption and, perhaps, empathy, one of the most important qualities a defense lawyer can bring to the representation of someone accused of a terrible crime. Albert Camus appears as well, through The Stranger and The Myth of Sisyphus, both of which I had also recently reread.

These were little moments of recognition. They made the reading experience strangely personal, but they were not what kept me thinking about the book after I finished it.

Camus is perhaps the most difficult of the references to place. The Stranger follows Meursault, a man whose emotional detachment sets him apart from those around him. Facing death, he comes to accept an indifferent universe. The Myth of Sisyphus takes up the problem of the absurd: our desire for meaning confronted with a world that offers none. Sisyphus is condemned to push the same rock uphill only to watch it roll back down, yet Camus sees in his conscious acceptance of that condition a form of freedom.

There is an important difference, however, between Meursault and Albert. Meursault does not resist the certainty of his execution. By the end of The Stranger, he has rejected the hope of escape and embraced what he sees as the indifference of the world. He even wishes for a large crowd at his execution, greeting him with cries of hatred, because that would make him feel less alone and complete what he has come to accept. Albert’s relationship with death is different. He does not appear to welcome death for recognition or attention. He seems to regard it as a way of ending the burden of living with what he has done. Nor is Albert Sisyphus. Sisyphus is condemned to continue pushing the rock, knowing that it will roll back down. Albert’s problem is almost the opposite. He appears to have stopped searching for a reason to continue. Sisyphus must find a way to live with the absurdity of continuing. Albert appears to have found no reason to continue at all.

The novel alludes to the connection but does not explain it. Ambiguity may be the point; Koufax and Albert may be drawing very different things from Camus, and the novel leaves us to decide what that difference means.

Frankl seems to bring us closer.

His question is not simply whether life has meaning in the abstract. It is how a person continues to live when circumstances, suffering, guilt, or despair make life seem meaningless. That question sits uneasily with Albert. He may not be searching for meaning at all. He may be searching for a way to stop living with what he has done.

And that leaves Koufax.

Koufax has a why. His why is to save his client. But as the case consumes him, another possibility emerges. Perhaps his determination to save Albert is also an attempt to save himself from the failure that has followed him for years. Perhaps he needs Albert to live almost as much as Albert seems to need to die.

That is what makes the novel linger.

It is not simply a story about whether Albert will live or die. It is about what happens when one person has lost his reason to live and another makes it his life’s work to find one for him. It is about vengeance and forgiveness, punishment and mercy, guilt and redemption. And beneath it all lies the uncomfortable possibility that the lawyer who sets out to save another may also be, consciously or not, trying to save himself.

That may be the deepest question Albert’s Time leaves behind: not whether Albert deserves to live, but whether either man can find a reason to live, if not happily, then at least with some measure of contentment.

Albert’s Time is a captivating read that I highly recommend.


Albert’s Time is being released December 17, 2026, you can order it now on Amazon, or wherever you buy your books.

Don't forget to leave your comments

About Author

Share

Author: Michael G. Karnavas

Michael G. Karnavas is an American trained lawyer. He is licensed in Alaska and Massachusetts and is qualified to appear before the various International tribunals, including the International Criminal Court (ICC). Residing and practicing primarily in The Hague, he is recognized as an expert in international criminal defence, including pre-trial, trial, and appellate advocacy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *